[REVIEW] Coming Home 归来

The 2014 Zhang Yimou film is a historical drama and family drama film set against the tumultuous events in Communist Chinese history where tragedy befalls and tears apart the Lu family. It stars Gong Li, who have collaborated with director Zhang for quite a few projects, Chen Daoming and Beijing Dance Academy graduate Zhang Huiwen (this movie is her debut role).

The beginning of the film reveals daughter Lu Dandan (Zhang Huiwen) training in a ballet troupe with rifles and marching, not like anything you would expect to see in a dance academy. Upon close observations on the walls one would notice that the ladies have pigtails and the walls are decorated with propaganda posters of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). And suddenly you become aware of why the dancers are dressed that way, it was the Cultural Revolution period. Although Dandan was a gifted and promising dancer, she is not given the lead role in the Red Detachment of Women (红色娘子军)and we later know that it is because her father Lu Yanshi (Chen Daoming) was a ‘rightist’ professor wanted by the government. Feeling indignant about the dance troupe’s decision, Dandan chooses to betray her disowned father and mother Wanyu (Gong Li) when they decided to meet up after years of not seeing each other by revealing the meetup information to the police. Consequently, the police arrives and arrests Yanshi.

Speed up time by a few years, Mao’s Cultural Revolution has ended and again, the story does not tell us directly. The change in lighting of the show, Dandan’s hairstyle and costumes reveal a change in era. Yanshi is released from prison but it was not his loving wife Wanyu waiting for him, it is their daughter instead. We later know that Gong Li’s character developed selective amnesia and she has forgotten how Yanshi looks like already. Yanshi then develops a series of strategies to evoke her memory which all failed miserably at the end and sometimes, leading to her ousting her husband out.

It is pretty touching at the beginning when we see Yanshi coming up with various ways to heal his wife, the love and effort was there for certain but over time, it all became too repetitive. At its film’s emotional climax where Yanshi exercised his fingers on the upright piano lying untouched in Wanyu’s living room, we see the couple crying. For a while, I expected a moment of epiphany and reunion but Zhang did not permit this celebratory event as later we see Wanyu pushing away Yanshi.

The film did not end on a high note as Wanyu eventually still failed to recognise Yanshi as her husband. Having admit to his fate, the former-rightist professor settled to be a kind stranger in Wanyu’s life, reading her letters written by him and sending her to the train station every 5th of the month. They are essentially living in two different time zone, one trapped in the past and the other hopelessly suffering in the present.

Coming Home is a brilliant film that touches on the cruel effects the Cultural Revolution brings to a family. Similar to The Road Home (1999), this tale talks about the undying love and passion shared between couples. But the film pales in comparison to other Zhang’s films such as Hero or The Road Home as it lacks any real action as all we see are repeated scenes of Yanshi’s failed efforts.


Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

[REVIEW] Farewell My Concubine 霸王别姬

This is my third Chen Kaige’s film after The Emperor and the Assassin 荆轲刺秦王 and The Orphan Zhao 赵氏孤儿 and as taught by my film professor, his films generally revolve around more complicated ideas. This was certainly the case in Chen’s 1993 work Farewell My Concubine which traces the lives of two Peking opera singers and best friends (played by Leslie Cheung and Zhang Feng Yi) against the backdrop of a changing Chinese society from its early Republic of China days to the end of the infamous Chinese Cultural Revolution.

While the movie itself is about the rigorous training sessions under the tutelage of the strict and stern Master Guan, who in modern context can be regarded as a person exploits child labour for profits, Farewell My Concubine is also a tale of blurred identities (real vs reel) and socio-political disturbances. When I watched this, I felt that the movie had a overall grim and sinister feels and I was constantly on the guard for something terrible that would happen to the characters. The opening scene, which introduced the two main characters Cheng Dieyi/Xiao Douzi (Leslie Cheung) and Duan Xiaolou/Xiao Shizi (Zhang Fengyi) in their complete make-up and opera costume, still gives me the creeps today. And it was also in this short 2 minutes did we get a brief understanding of the political effects (Gang of Four 四人帮) on the characters.


Chinese opera has been an irreplaceable and timeless cultural element in China and is fairly easily distinguishable from their almost fully white-painted faces and vivid costumes. Among the other genres of opera in Chinese culture such as Cantonese opera, kunqu, huangmei opera, the form seen in Farewell My Concubine is the Peking opera. Since the Qing Dynasty where the Hui opera was first brought into the Chinese capital Beijing, Peking opera has continuously evolved over the centuries to be the most well-known genre today.

One feature of the Peking opera is the use of males for all characters on stage, even for the female parts dan. This would later form the basis of confusion of Xiao Douzi/Cheng Dieyi’s gender identity in the movie.


“A performance on stage may just be three minutes but it requires ten years of practice.”

Loosely translated to English, this Chinese quote means “A performance on stage may just be three minutes but it requires ten years of practice.” and this quote has never been more true. In the 1924 segment, we see a young Xiao Shizi and other young boys attempting to escape the public performance of his opera troupe only to end up getting disciplined by their master. What is interesting to note is the screen gradually transits from black-and-white to pale and depressing shades of colours. The change in colours suggests the role Peking opera does in reinstalling energy and life into society but the dull tones express a darker truth lurking beneath it.

The subsequent few minutes are about the boys, scrawny and seemingly disciplined, engaged in a diverse form of physical training while reciting lines from the opera. Though one may have recited accurately, he is beaten on his hands so that he will remember the lines in the future. Meanwhile, Xiao Douzi, a boy with feminine looks, is taught the dan roles. While training for the opera si fan (思凡), Xiao Douzi frequently messes the line “I am by nature a girl, not a boy” with “I am by nature a boy, not a girl” and this irritates the master who gave Xiao Douzi a severe whipping that left his hands bleeding. In one instance, the character was also sexually abused by eunuch Zhang after the troupe performed for him.


I am a male, not a female

The near absence of non-diegetic sounds, formal conversations and low lighting used in the characters’ teenage period only set the show for a gloomier tone. In the adult years, we subsequently see the emotional struggles Xiao Shizi, now known as Cheng Dieyi, who wrestles between his sexual identity and his love for his best friend and co-worker Xiao Shizi/Duan Xiaolou who is attracted to courtesan Juxian (played by Gong Li). Topping it off, the Peking opera comes under attack during the infamous Mao’s Cultural Revolution which rid a huge part of the Chinese culture.


Having suffered under the tutelage of the troupe owners over the “I am by nature a girl, not a boy” line which Cheng Dieyi is forced to remember, he MAY have grown up and chose to identify as a girl liking a boy (Duan Xiaolou). And this is when the lines get blurred. While Duan Xiaolou was able to differentiate his life career and his personal life, Cheng Dieyi longs for a relationship with his on-stage partner. It is not explicitly stated whether Duan Xiaolou is aware of Cheng’s interest for him but their relationship became awkward and complicated with the former’s marriage to Juxian.

The series of unfortunate and tragic events is sadly not resolved in the story line and went on till the final scene where Cheng Dieyi resolved to commit suicide. Fast forward to the Cultural Revolution period where many were persecuted, we soon enter a period dominated by fear and terror especially for those in the arts and theater industry. Unfortunately for our main characters, famous stage actors before the Cultural Revolution, they are not left out either. When confronted by the Red Guards in a public struggle session, the two friends betray each other and let out each other’s secrets including the ones where Cheng performed for the Japanese during the Japanese Occupation and Xiaolou’s relationship with Juxian, a courtesan. Feeling betrayed by Xiaolou’s actions, Juxian hung herself in her apartment – the second of the third suicide cases in the film.

Once again there was a time jump and we are presented a China after Mao’s death. Under the leadership of Deng Xiaoping, China was preparing its way for economic liberalisation. The best friends, Xiaolou and Dieyi, have amended their friendship and are seen performing the play Farewell My Concubine except that in this version, Dieyi chose to kill himself with the sword as though marking symbolic death of the opera culture.

The movie aims to show and not tell, making audiences speculate on what has and is about to happen next. Its plot has few comical scenes and overall, just serious dialogues between the characters. As mentioned earlier, Farewell My Concubine has little to no non-diegetic sounds and this creates a feeling that we audience are there experiencing the tragedy that befalls the characters, as though what we are viewing is real and not made-up.

Overall, the movie is great in showcasing themes such as homosexuality, the brutality of the Communist China regime under Mao and of course Chinese culture.


Rating: 4 out of 5.